张耀文,白洁,王磊,刘卓,张一帆
ZHANG Yaowen,BAI Jie,WANG Lei,LIU Zhuo,ZHANG Yifan

• 1:内蒙古电力(集团)有限责任公司内蒙古电力科学研究院分公司
• 2:内蒙古自治区高电压与绝缘技术企业重点实验室
• 3:内蒙古电力(集团)有限责任公司

摘要(Abstract)：

针对采用直线法测试大型接地网接地阻抗时，线间互感会对测试结果产生较大影响的问题，采取算数修正的方法，对某电厂通过直线法获取的初始结果进行修正运算，结果低于该厂接地网接地阻抗设计值，有效消除了线间互感带来的误差。通过误差分析可以看出，该方法与远离夹角法所测数据的误差在可接受范围内，验证了该修正直线法对于消除线间互感、获得接地阻抗准确数据的有效性。
For some large grounding grids without the condition of distance angle method to test grounding impedance, the straight-line method is usually adopted. However, the mutual inductance between lines that cannot be ignored will have a great influence on the test result. In this paper, an arithmetic correction method is adopted to correct the initial results obtained by linear method in a power plant, and the results are lower than the design value of the ground impedance of the grounding grid of the plant, which effectively eliminates the errors caused by mutual inductance between lines. The error analysis shows that the error of the value between this method and the distance angle method is within an acceptable range, which means that compared with the initial measured results, this modified straight line method is very effective in eliminating mutual inductance between wires and obtaining accurate data of grounding impedance.

关键词(KeyWords)： 接地网;接地阻抗;修正直线法;线间互感;误差
grounding grid;grounding impedance;modified straight-line method;mutual inductance between lines;error

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation):

作者(Author): 张耀文,白洁,王磊,刘卓,张一帆
ZHANG Yaowen,BAI Jie,WANG Lei,LIU Zhuo,ZHANG Yifan

参考文献(References)：

• [1]薛雯娟.大型接地网安全性及接地阻抗测量案例分析[J].电气时代，2022(1):81-82,86.XUE Wenjuan. Case analysis of large grounding grid safety and grounding impedance measurement[J]. Electric Age, 2022(1):81-82, 86.
• [2]李伟，王伟，孙永春，等.应用CDEGS进行变电站接地网设计流程的研究[J].电瓷避雷器，2022(5):113-118.LI Wei, WANG Wei, SUN Yongchun, et al. Application of CDEGS to study the design process of substation grounding grid[J]. Insulators and Surge Arresters, 2022(5):13-118.
• [3]王斯琪，胡晓晖，王强.JJG 1180—2021《大型接地网工频接地阻抗测试仪检定规程》解读[J].中国计量，2022(10):145-149.WANG Siqi, HU Xiaohui, WANG Qiang. Interpretation of JJG1180-2021′Verification Regulation of Grounding Impedance Tester for Large Grounding Grid′[J]. China Metrology, 2022(10):145-149.
• [4]李永晨，李传东.一起6 kV系统高阻接地故障的查找及分析[J].电世界，2022,63(4):15-17.LI Yongchen, LI Chuandong. Finding and Analysis of a High Resistance Grounding Fault in 6 kV System[J]. Electric World,2022, 63(4):15-17.
• [5]熊舟，杨烽，何强.基于异频法的大型水电站接地网接地阻抗测量实践[J].水电站机电技术，2022,45(7):78-81.XIONG Zhou, YANG Feng, HE Qiang. Grounding impedance measurement practice of large hydropower station grounding grid based on different frequency method[J]. Mechanical&Electrical Technique of Hydropower Station, 2022, 45(7):78-81.
• [6]何智强，张宣，严雅琳，等.利用架空线测量接地阻抗时的互感问题分析[J].电瓷避雷器，2022(3):116-122.HE Zhiqiang, ZHANG Xuan, YAN Yalin, et al. Analysis of mutual inductance problem when measuring grounding impedance by overhead line[J]. Insulators and Surge Arresters, 2022(3):116-122.
• [7]李国胜，郑雪，罗福玲.大型钢接地网的接地阻抗计算与测量分析[J].电瓷避雷器，2022(2):109-114.LI Guosheng, ZHENG Xue, LUO Fuling. Grounding impedance calculation and measurement analysis of large steel grounding Grid[J]. Insulators and Surge Arresters, 2022(2):109-114.
• [8]侯苏洋，郝婷婷，于洋，等.引线间互感对接地阻抗测量结果的影响分析[J].电瓷避雷器，2019(3):52-56,62.HOU Suyang, HAO Tingting, YU Yang, et al. Analysis of the influence of mutual inductance between leads on the measurement results of grounding impedance[J]. Insulators and Surge Arresters,2019(3):52-56, 62.
• [9]段长君，格日勒图，李智辉，等.基于分流相移法的大型接地网接地阻抗测试分析[J].内蒙古电力技术，2018,36(5):35-38,42.DUAN Changjun, Geriletu, LI Zhihui, et al. Analysis of grounding impedance test of large grounding grid based on shunt phase shift method[J]. Inner Mongolia Electric Power,2018, 36(5):35-38, 42.
• [10]杨坤.220 kV变电站接地电阻计算及接触电压和跨步电压校验[J].智能建筑电气技术，2022,16(5):45-49.YANG Kun. 220 kV substation grounding resistance calculation and contact voltage and step voltage calibration[J]. Electrical Technology of Intelligent Buildings, 2022, 16(5):45-49.
• [11]李冠华，徐凯，董雪晴，等.变电站接地阻抗降阻措施评估方法[J].沈阳工业大学学报，2022,44(1):14-19.LI Guanhua, XU Kai, DONG Xueqing, et al. Evaluation method of substation grounding impedance resistance reduction measures[J]. Journal of Shenyang University of Technology,2022, 44(1):14-19.
• [12]王业斌，朱浩，孙浩，等.发电厂接地装置接地阻抗测量方法对比和分析[J].电工技术，2021(21):128-131,135.WANG Yebin, ZHU Hao, SUN Hao, et al. Comparison and analysis of grounding impedance measurement methods for grounding devices in power plants[J]. Electric Engineering,2021(21):128-131, 135.
• [13]何智杰，傅炜婷，林燕桢，等.基于CDEGS频响参数计算的电网谐波对变电站接地网接地阻抗研究和应用[C]//福建省电机工程学会.福建省电机工程学会2020年学术年会获奖论文集（上册）.福州：福建科学技术出版社，2021:208-212.
• [14]余炜，余云光，沈映，等.基于CDEGS探讨分层土壤结构下大型接地网埋深对接地阻抗值的影响[J].电力设备管理，2021(8):67-68.YU Wei, YU Yunguang, SHEN Ying, et al. Based on CDEGS, the influence of buried depth of large grounding grid on grounding impedance value under layered soil structure is discussed[J]. Electric Power Equipment Management, 2021(8):67-68.
• [15]旦乙画.水平分层土壤中腐蚀接地网接地参数计算方法研究[D].重庆：重庆大学，2021.
• [16]余炜，余云光，王允光，等.基于CDEGS变电站大型接地网安全性状态诊断及分析[J].电力设备管理，2021(4):67-69.YU Wei, YU Yunguang, WANG Yunguang, et al. Based on the safety status diagnosis and analysis of large grounding grid in CDEGS substation[J]. Electric Power Equipment Management, 2021(4):67-69.
• [17]国家能源局.接地装置特性参数测量导则：DL/T 475—2017[S].北京：中国电力出版社，2017.
• [18]郭博文，李松原，张锡喆.基于直线法的大型变电站接地阻抗测量修正法[J].电瓷避雷器，2021(3):105-111.GUO Bowen, LI Songyuan, ZHANG Xizhe. Correction method of grounding impedance measurement for large substation based on straight line method[J]. Insulators and Surge Arresters,2021(3):105-111.
• [19]申巍，樊镒铖，王森，等.分层土壤短距离放线下接地电阻测试方法研究[J].智慧电力，2022,50(12):13-18,93.SHEN Wei, FAN Yicheng, WANG Sen, et al. Measuring Method of Grounding Resistance under Short Distance Laying-out in Layered Soil[J]. Smart Power, 2022, 50(12):13-18, 93.
• [20] LIMA, ANTONIO C. S., MOURA, et al. A Computational Improvement in Grounding Systems Transient Analysis[J].IEEE Transactions on Electromagnetic Compatibility, 2020, 62(3):765-773.
• [21] YUAN Haobo, ZHOU Hongguang, LIU Hongwei, et al. Computing Mutual Impedance of Antennas by Spherical Harmonic Transform[J]. IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation,2019, 67(7):4377-4384.
• [22] MA Junjie. Fast and high-precision calculation of earth return mutual impedance between conductors over a multilayered soil[J]. COMPEL:The international journal for computation and mathematics in electrical and electronic engineering, 2018, 37(3):1214-1227.
• [23]王琰.基于接地模型实测的接地装置阻抗值影响因素分析[J].集成电路应用，2021,38(2):40-41.WANG Yan. Analysis of Influencing Factors of Grounding Device Impedance Based on Grounding Model Measurement[J].Applications of IC, 2021, 38(2):40-41.
• [24]袁培，何智强，胡晓晖，等.考虑大地影响的直线法测量大型地网的接地阻抗[J].中国电力，2018,51(7):36-42.YUAN Pei, HE Zhiqiang, HU Xiaohui, et al. Considering the influence of the earth, the linear method is used to measure the grounding impedance of large grounding grid[J]. Electric Power, 2018, 51(7):36-42.
• [25]马御棠，张博成，周仿荣，等.消除引线互感影响的地网接地阻抗测量方法[J].电瓷避雷器，2017(4):73-77.MA Yutang, ZHANG Bocheng, ZHOU Fangrong, et al.Ground network grounding impedance measurement method to eliminate the influence of lead mutual inductance[J].Insulators and Surge Arresters, 2017(4):73-77.
• [26]闫旭，杨文良，王振中，等.输变电设备接地装置阻抗值影响因素分析[J].电工技术，2021(15):133-134,137.YAN Xu, YANG Wenliang, WANG Zhenzhong, et al. Analysis of Factors Affecting the Ground Impedance Value of Transmission and Transformation Equipment[J]. Electric Engineering, 2021(15):133-134,
• [27]徐碧川，万华，龙国华，等.接地网接地阻抗测试方法误差分析[J].江西电力，2018(2):21-25.XU Bichuan, WAN Hua, LONG Guohua, et al. Error analysis of grounding grid grounding impedance test method[J]. Jiangxi Electric Power, 2018(2):21-25.
• [28]张凯军，胡志坚，张博成.计及地线耦合的利用架空线路测量接地网接地阻抗的方法[J].电测与仪表，2017(12):7-13.ZHANG Kaijun, HU Zhijian, ZHANG Bocheng. Method for measuring grounding impedance of grounding grids using overhead lines considering ground coupling[J]. Electrical Measurement&Instrumentation, 2017(12):7-13.
• [29]王森，李伟，李柯，等.分层土壤模型下大型接地网冲击特性研究[J].电瓷避雷器，2021(4):30-34.WANG Sen, LI Wei, LI Ke, et al. Impact characteristics of large grounding grid under layered soil model[J]. Insulators and Surge Arresters, 2021(4):30-34.
• [30]杨波，陈宇燕，陈明华.基于CDEGS的变电站接地网接地电阻的仿真与研究[J].红水河，2021,40(4):97-101.YANG Bo, CHEN Yuyan, CHEN Minghua. Simulation and Research on Grounding Resistance of Substation Grounding Grid Based on CDEGS[J]. Hongshui River, 2021, 40(4):97-101.
• [31]范贤达，黄琛.电力系统的接地技术分析与展望[J].集成电路应用，2021,38(6):78-79.FAN Xianda, HUANG Chen. Analysis and Prospect of Grounding Technology in Power System[J]. Applications of IC,2021, 38(6):78-79.
• [32]李雄，陆家榆，曹方圆，等.考虑非线性极化时不同土壤电阻率下直流接地极电流对油气管道的腐蚀影响分析[J].电网技术，2022,46(12):5021-5028.LI Xiong, LU Jiayu, CAO Fangyuan, et al. Effect of DC grounding electrode current on corrosion of oil and gas pipelines under different soil resistivity considering nonlinear polarization[J]. Power System Technology, 2022, 46(12):5021-5028.